Season 23 of American Idol crowned Jamal Roberts the winner on May 18, 2025, but many fans weren’t pleased. Although Roberts celebrated his win holding his daughters in a heartfelt Facebook post, social media quickly flooded with backlash, with supporters insisting runner-up John Foster was more deserving. “John was robbed,” one fan wrote, while another claimed, “I will not watch next season.”

Despite some congratulating Jamal, comments like “John should have won. He was so natural,” captured the overall mood. Still, one fan added, “Now John Foster isn’t bound to the Idol contract,” suggesting a silver lining.

Controversy didn’t stop there. Judge Carrie Underwood also faced heat for her critiques and fashion choices during Disney Night. “Her bias is showing,” one critic wrote, while others defended her, saying, “Do whatever you want 💫.”

The top 3 finalists – Roberts, Foster, and Breanna Nix – delivered standout Disney-themed performances, but the finale’s results and judging sparked intense debate online, ensuring this season ends with more drama than ever.