Some relationship debates begin quietly, but others strike a nerve almost instantly. That’s what happened when dating coach Jake Maddock shared one firm rule he believes every committed couple should follow.

Maddock says a woman should block any man her partner is uncomfortable with, without asking why. In his view, this simple act shows loyalty and protects the relationship. He even shared that his own wife blocked a male friend early in their dating stage, and he saw it as a sign of commitment.

But his advice quickly took a sharp turn online. Many viewers argued that healthy relationships require trust and honest conversations, not instant obedience. They said boundaries should be shared decisions, especially when old friends or harmless connections are involved.

Others warned that Maddock’s rule could slide into controlling behavior. They pointed out that demanding someone cut people off without discussion can be a red flag. Some even said it could be used to isolate a partner or hide deeper insecurity.

Still, a few agreed that removing potential temptations can help couples avoid problems before they start. They stressed that if romantic interest exists, blocking might be the simplest solution. But even they said the choice should come from respect, not pressure.

The debate continues to spread, reminding people that every couple handles trust differently — and the healthiest choices are usually built on communication, not commands.